Decided on 5 stars. Why? Because I couldn't decide if the lack of finish on the inside was a downer. But the craftmanship is so meticulously applied everywhere, hinges, lock, padlock, alignment, you can tell whoever makes these boxes cares. Even if it's on a line, they all care, because it is so well crafted that the lack of interior finishing (no waxing or polishing on inside, nor satin lining) was not a deal breaker on the stars. Just look at it! Also, the padlock was so very clever. There were no instructions in mine for the correct unlock code. So I decided it must be something simple. Maybe it was meant to be a little puzzle. There are 3 sets of 0-9 to choose. Hmm... 3 numbers. Choose 3 numbers. Choose a number 3 times. Hmm.